Funny how economic statistics sometimes mean something and sometimes don't -- even when released on the same day and appearing to be somewhat inconsistent. But apparently perception is more important that reality because the Consumer Confidence Index (a simplistic measure of consumer sentiment and perception) rose to 54.9% in April from 40.8% in May whereas the S&P/Case-Shiller National Home Price Index fell at a record annual pace of 19.1%. Stated simply, home prices continue to decline at the fastest rate in history with no relief in sight. We have perception unsupported by behavior, on the one hand, versus a report detailing actual, not supposed or possible behavior, on the other hand. Stock market reaction: positive perception sounds better than negative reality ... let's rally on karma.
Aside from slumping real estate values, consumer credit continues to shrink and unemployment is expected to crest somewhere over 10% but not until next year. Sounds like eroding buying power to me, but I tend to prefer economic indicators based on facts, not unrealized fantasy. So how can consumer confidence rise so dramatically when home prices are falling so dramatically? A very good question but I doubt they asked it to the 5,000 households comprising the Consumer Confidence Index.
But let's try to look at this dispassionately. Where is consumer buying power going to come from as credit card debt limits contract and new credit card debt will likely carry higher interest rates at least once the just passed Credit Card Bill of Rights goes into effect. Moreover, home equity lines are no longer available at anywhere near the dollar level (we're talking trillions here) before the current financial crisis as 30% of the homes in this country already are underwater on their mortgages. So, who is going to fund the recovery when the statistical recession ends. The increasing number of unemployed and those who fear for loss of their jobs as well? Or others without access to credit?
Have you seen the empty stores lining the malls, at least in the malls that are not yet shuttered? Apparently, that doesn't matter to the bulls either because unemployment and lost real estate values are already factored into the the stock market. The bulls say, "it can't get much worse." Does that Orwellian thinking equate to additional dollars at the cash register or make you feel "confident"?
The market, say the perma-bulls explicitly or by implicaton, is discounting all of the actual negative news because there are people saying that they are more confident about the economy. I don't buy that Twitteresque status report. Rather, I think this rally is nothing more that a "ponzi" scheme of sorts. The Wall Street gang keeps telling everyone that the sky isn't falling so the retail investor, directly or indirectly through increased inflows to mutual funds, will buy stock even though there is very little, if any, real reason to do so. Finally, when the over $1 trillion of bonds supported by cratering real estate craters, the stock market will follow suit.
Have we learned nothing in the last year? Inflated real estate values, coupled with egregious underwriting standards and ill-conceived governmental policy, led to the real estate bubble. Now, the same robber-barons that levered us into this mess are trying to suck everybody back into the game. And the Obama Administration and the Federal Reserve are all adding to this frenzy. The FED is printing money with reckless abandon and buying back the Treasury Bonds it issues to finance the debt. In other words, the FED is buying back the debt it issued with phony money. The debt that the Chinese and the OPEC countries no longer want to purchase without assurances that their investment won't be flushed down the toilet with all the toilet paper being manufactured by the FED.
We are issuing debt in this country as if we don't have to pay it back or with the assumption that people will buy it and agree to be paid back with dollars that are worth less in the future. We are headed for inflation armageddon unless we can somehow snooker foreign investors back to the casino where they lose no matter how they play. What do I mean by that? If they continue to finance the U.S. debt unabated, they will surely lose value on their investment as the dollar is devalued due to gargantuan future U.S. debt obligations. If they stop buying U.S. debt, the FED still continues to crank out bogus money now (as opposed to later to pay back debt in the former scenario), thereby destroying the value of current debtholders' investments in U.S. bonds and currency.
But everything is rip-roaringly fine according to the same characters who didn't think they could lose with 30 or 40 to 1 leverage. Yet, they did. How's that consumer confidence going for you now?
No comments:
Post a Comment